Rigid dump trucks (RDT) are high-capacity off-road vehicles that work well with hydraulic excavators. These machines are exceptionally dependable in a range of key operations due to a huge number of unique characteristics. Today, we are going to checkout trucks from the two most famous brands in truck manufacturing.
One is Tata Hitachi. Dump truck types from Tata Hitachi are developed to suit specific load-size requirements in mining, quarrying, and construction. RDTs have superior suspension systems, a distinctive body design, and a dependable electrical system. For decades, these vehicles have had a stellar reputation for dependability, performance, and efficiency.
You may like to read: Best 5 Trucks Companies for Transport and Commercial Use
Comparison Between Bharat Benz Truck vs Tata Hitachi Truck
Check out the complete comparison between the BharatBenz 2528CM and the Tata LPK 2518! Compare the two models based on their Price(Cost), Size(Dimension), Fuel Type, Load Capacity (Payload), GCV, Mileage, Features, and other specifications to determine which truck is ideal for you. Ex-showroom prices for the BharatBenz 2528CM and Tata LPK 2518 start at 39.1 lacs as well as 28.19 lacs, respectively. BharatBenz 2528CM has a 6372 cc engine while Tata LPK 2518 has a 5883 cc engine.
The Cummins ISBe 5.9 180 40 engine of the Tata LPK 2518 conforms with BS-IV emission regulations. The engine can deliver a maximum power of 134 kW at 2500 rpm and a maximum torque of 700 Nm at 1500 rpm. The heavy-duty engine has a displacement of 5883 cubic centimeters. The fuel tank capacity is 300 ltr, and the vehicle's GVW is 25000 kg.
Related Article: Top 3 Cars under Rs. 5 Lakh, Specifications, Features, and Price
Performance
The tipper BharatBenz 2528CM has a gross vehicle weight of 25000 kg. The 6373cc, 6 cylinder DE210BS4 SCR technology engine powers this BharatBenz tipper. The BharatBenz 2528CM tipper has a maximum torque of 1120 Nm and a power output of 281 HP. This BharatBenz 2528CM tipper's engine is mated to a 9-speed manual transmission (9F+1R).
The Tata LPK 2518 HD is a tipper designed for the mining and construction industries to transport loads such as coal, stone, gravel, sand, concrete, and other materials. The tipper's gross vehicle weight is 25,000 kg. This truck's ex-showroom pricing is INR 27.7 lakh, with a 3,880 mm wheelbase choice and two body variants of the box and scoop with load capacities of 16, 14, and 12 CuM.
| Truck Model | Bharat Benz 2528CM | Tata LPK 2518 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Rs 39.1 lacs (ex-showroom) | Rs 28.19 lacs (ex-showroom) |
| Engine | De210 | Cummins Is Be5.9 180 40 |
| Engine Cylinders | 6 | 6 |
| Emission Norms | BS-Vi | BS-Vi |
| Displacement | 6372 cc | 5883 cc |
| Transmission | Manual | Manual |
| Torque | 1120 Nm @ 1200 (1600 Rpm) | 700 Nm @ 1500 Rpm |
| Power | 281bhp @ 2200 Rpm | 180 Bhp @ 2500 Rpm |
| Clutch | Hydraulic Control With Clutch Booster, Single Dry Plate, 430 Mm | Single Plate (Dry Friction) 383 mm |
| Gearbox | 9 Speed | 9 Speed |
| gradability | 80% | 28% |
| Max Speed | 60 km/h | - |
| Fuel Tank | 290 | 300 |
Safety
The axle arrangement of this BharatBenz 2528CM tipper is 6x4. The BharatBenz 2528CM tipper's chassis is a channel section with cross members. The rear suspension of the 2528CM tipper is handled by bogie suspension. Air brakes and seat belts are included in the BharatBenz 2528CM's safety features.Tata Hitachi Truck Showrooms in India: Tata Hitachi Dealer Locator
Whereas, The Tata tipper is fitted with a complete air S cam braking system, which gives this commercial truck plenty of stopping power. The vehicle does not come with anti-lock brakes from Tata Motors. The front cabin is composed of solid steel, which ensures the driver and other passengers' safety. The large 20-inch tires aid in retaining decent road grip. According to Tata, the vehicle has a peak gradeability of approximately 29%.
| Brakes | Pneumatic | Air Brakes |
|---|---|---|
| Front Suspension | Parabolic Type Leaf Spring (2 Hydraulic Shock Absorbers) | - |
| Rear Suspension | Inverted Semi Elliptical Tandem Bogie | - |
| Front Axle | Reverse Elliot | Reverse Elliot Type |
| Rear Axle | Topoid Gears, Hub Reduction Axle Ra2 - (Irt390t-11) | Extra Heavy Duty Hypoid Gears Fully Floating Axle Shafts - RA 109srt |
| Power Steering | Yes | Yes |
| Parking Brakes | Yes | Yes |
| ABS | Yes | No |
| Seat Belt | Yes | Yes |
| Tubeless tires | Yes | No |
| Hill Hold | Yes | No |
Design & Dimensions
BharatBenz heavy-duty tipper trucks are known for their high fuel efficiency. Its high-efficiency mill, along with cutting-edge technology, ensures the best possible mileage. This will also help to lower the cost of each trip and allow you to earn more money. The interior has power steering, which enhances the driving experience and makes maneuvering easier. There are also some other important features, such as the driver information display, armrest, telematics, and flexible driver seat, among others.Bharat Benz Truck Showrooms in India: Bharat Benz Dealer Locator
Whereas tata Hitachi has power steering and a gradeability of 42 percent is sufficient for comfortable driving. Standard features in the cabin include an ergonomic design, standard seats, an instrument cluster, and much more.
| Wheelbase | 6775 mm | 6200 mm |
| Total length | 7160 mm | 7060 mm |
| Total width | 2490 mm | - |
| Total height | 2975 mm | - |
| Ground Clearance | 234 mm | 235 mm |
| GVW | 25000 kgs | 25000 kgs |
| Cabin | Day Cabin | Day Cabin |
| Body Design | Box Body | Box Body |
Verdict
According to us, both the trucks has some positive point and at some point one is one of them is dominating the other. So, choose the best as per your convenience.
